Opinion
Update on Endangered Species Protection in Canada
Laura Telford
Canadian Nature Federation,1 Nicholas Street, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, K1N
7B7; ltelford@cnf.ca
Abstract
The Canadian government introduced the Species at Risk Act in April 2000.
In its current form, the legislation is weak and will do little to halt the
slide towards extinction of many Canadian species. Unlike the U.S. Endangered
Species Act, which contains clear prohibitions against the harming of species
and their habitats wherever they reside, many of the provisions in the Canadian
Act rely on the discretion of politicians to act in a manner which is beneficial
to species at risk. The legislation contains no automatic protection for the
habitat of species at risk (loss of habitat is the primary cause of species
endangerment) and the scope of the prohibitions against harming of individual
species at risk and their residences is limited to federal lands (excluding
the three northern territories which are under federal authority), some migratory
birds, and some aquatic species. Species that migrate across the Canada-U.S.
border are not specifically ad-dressed
by the legislation. Final decisions about which species will be listed, and
therefore
receive legal protection, will be left up to politicians, not scientists.
The current Act does not fulfill all of Canada's commitments under international
and national agreements, nor does it live up to the government's own promises
or meet the expectations of the majority of Canadians who believe that the
federal government should take the lead role in protecting species at risk.