|
EARLY WEST COAST
YEARS (1917–1943)
Lou Harrison was born in Portland, Oregon, on May
14, 1917, but spent his formative years in northern California, where
his family relocated when he was nine. The Harrisons moved from one
California town to another almost annually between 1926 and 1934:
Woodland, Sacramento, Stockton, Berkeley, San Francisco, Los Gatos,
Redwood City, Belmont, and Burlingame.15
Lou and his younger brother Bill had little opportunity to develop
long-lasting friendships. Instead Lou carried a small trunk of
mementos from place to place: "It was my little life. Since I ...
had no chance to have a peer group or any roots ... I made an
imaginary world and carried it around in paper and books."16
To this day, Harrison is a collector and accumulator—of books,
artwork, and his own programs, scores, and reviews. Unlike many other
composers, he has not destroyed notebooks, sketches, or early
compositions, preserving the history of individual works as well as
the development of his compositional process. When faced with a new
commission, Harrison frequently revisits old pieces, at times
selecting fragments from unfinished works and at other times
refashioning completed pieces in new guises: "The gods are always
kind and leave us with things to do," he says.17
He has kept many volumes of his writings as well—his early poetry,
for instance, and even general musings on a wide range of topics, both
musical and non-musical. Harrison’s mother,
Calline ("Cal") Lillian Silver Harrison, assured her sons a
thorough grounding in the performing arts by sending them regularly to
dance and music lessons, and encouraging their interest in the
theater. Lou first appeared on the stage at the age of two-and-a-half
in a production of Jean Webster’s Daddy Long Legs, and even
toured the Northwest with the Portland stock company that mounted the
show.18
(His improvisatory antics on the stage inspired delighted commentary
from newspaper reviewers.) Cal also gave her sons an ecumenical
religious training, changing denominations whenever they moved—and
sometimes more often than that. Harrison also attributes to his mother
his political consciousness, his embrace of racial and cultural
diversity, and his love of Asian art. ("Mom also gave me her gene
Xq28, which predisposes me to like other males," he announced in
a 1997 talk; "It works too.")19
After graduating from Burlingame High School in
December 1934, Harrison attended San Francisco State College (now
University) for three semesters, where he studied french horn and
clarinet, took up harpsichord and recorder, and sang in several vocal
ensembles. Throughout his San Francisco years he performed Renaissance
and Baroque music on early instruments and wrote compositions for
harpsichord, clavichord, recorder, and other historical instruments,
among them a frequently-performed set of six harpsichord sonatas.20
Over the years Harrison has also built replicas of early instruments,
including two clavichords and several versions of the ancient Greek
aulos, efforts that set the stage for his later large-scale
instrument-building projects (many completed in collaboration with his
partner, Bill Colvig)— including harps, metallophones, Chinese and
Korean instruments, and three gamelan.
Pre-classical styles and formal structures have
informed Harrison’s music ever since these San Francisco
experiences: he has written sarabandes (several works from the 1930s),
ductias (Suite for Symphonic Strings, 1960; Rhymes with
Silver, 1996), and a conductus (Suite for Piano, 1943), as
well as a dozen estampies (in works from 1960 to 1997)—lively
medieval dances characterized by whirling melodies set against a
rhythmic percussion accompaniment.
A seminal event in Harrison’s career was his
enrollment in the spring of 1935 in Henry Cowell’s course
"Music of the Peoples of the World" at the University of
California Extension in San Francisco. It was here that Harrison first
heard gamelan music,21
from recordings that Cowell had brought back from his studies in
1931–32 at the Berlin Phonogramm-Archiv (directed from 1906–33 by
Erich von Hornbostel). The following autumn Harrison began private
composition lessons with Cowell,22
who became (and would remain) one of the strongest musical influences
in Harrison’s life. In addition to encouraging Harrison to explore
new instrumental resources, Cowell taught his students the importance
of melody and gave them guided exercises in writing diverse forms of
counterpoint.23
He also helped Harrison forge important professional relationships,
recommending him for a position as dance accompanist at Mills College24
and facilitating his interactions with Arnold Schoenberg, Edgard
Varèse,
Carl Ruggles, and Charles Ives.
On March 25, 1936, Harrison wrote to Ives at
Cowell’s suggestion: "I am a student at State College in San
Francisco. It seems that there are favorable opportunities to perform
your works on what we have as student recitals and in theory and
history classes."25
Ives obliged by sending two piano sonatas, and in December 1936, after
additional correspondence and requests, had his nephew Chester Ives
send Harrison a crate of photostats that included most of Ives’s
chamber music, songs, and several orchestral works. Harrison studied
these pieces at the piano almost daily over a ten-year period. Despite
the tentative nature of this initial contact, Harrison would
eventually play an important role in the restoration and dissemination
of Ives’s music, editing several works after he moved to New York in
1943. He orchestrated Ives’s song, They are There! and edited
the Third Symphony, First Piano Sonata, and Second String
Quartet. Working from a corrupt source, Harrison also
reconstructed a portion of the Robert Browning Overture with
such accuracy that when the original score of the work finally
surfaced, the reconstruction was found to be nearly identical to the
original.
Among the other friendships instigated by Cowell was
that between Harrison and John Cage. Early in the summer of 1938 Cage
appeared unannounced at Harrison’s San Francisco apartment. He had
sought out Harrison at Cowell’s suggestion: "I knew that [Lou]
shared with me the love of the modern dance," Cage recalled many
years later, "and I needed a job."26
As Cowell suspected, the two men found much in common and developed a
close collaboration as well as a lifelong friendship. Harrison
recommended Cage to the dancer and choreographer Bonnie Bird, who was
seeking an accompanist for her classes at the Cornish School in
Seattle (a job Cage held for two years),27
and made sure that Mills College, where Harrison was on the staff,
invited Cage to its summer festivals in 1939 and 1940. (According to
Bird’s biographer, the Cornish position was first offered to
Harrison, who declined.)28
During these summer festivals and after Cage’s return to San
Francisco in 1940, the two men staged high-profile percussion concerts
using a variety of novel instruments. For one of these performances at
the California Club in 1941, they even wrote a joint composition: the
percussion quartet Double Music.29
Harrison and Cage’s compositions for percussion
were an outgrowth of their collaborations with modern dancers.30
In San Francisco, Harrison wrote music for Carol Beals and Lenore
Peters Job; at Mills he collaborated with Tina Flade, Marian van Tuyl,
and Los Angeles choreographer Lester Horton, who spent two summer
sessions in Oakland with his assistant, the now renowned Bella
Lewitzky. Harrison even danced in several staged productions—at the
War Memorial Opera House (where he played the part of Winter in Harvey
Raab’s opera Ming-Yi), at the Curran Theater (in Changing
World ,for which he also wrote the score and helped with the
choreography), and at the Lucie Stern Grove (in Green Mansions,
where he played the role of Abel, dancing to his own music and
performing in the percussion ensemble).31
Harrison also wrote percussion music for the concert
hall. Among his works from this period are a number of concerti for
solo instrument and percussion, including one for flute (1939), which
is performed frequently and has been recorded three times, and an
equally popular one for violin (completed in 1959).32
He also began a mass for voices and percussion, occasioned by
Hitler’s invasion of Poland in September 1939 (although he changed
its scoring to trumpet, harp, and strings in 1952). The opening motive
in the "Kyrie" is his "cry of anguish" over the
impending war, the "Gloria" his plea for world unity with an
outburst of bells.33
This Mass to St. Anthony also reflects Harrison’s interest in
Native American and California mission music, evidenced by other works
throughout his career (Sanctus, 1940; Strict Songs,
1955; Fourth Symphony, 1990). The many
percussion works Harrison composed in the 1930s–40s not only have
formed an essential core of the present-day percussion repertoire, but
also have served as a continuing influence on his later compositions.
In addition to substituting the percussion orchestra for the
traditional orchestra in concerti,34
Harrison has often called on melodic instruments for percussive
effects: tapping on the body of the instrument (String Quartet Set,
1979), beating the strings of a double bass with drumsticks below the
bridge (Solstice, 1950), or striking rapid clusters on the
keyboard with an octave bar (Concerto for Organ with Percussion
Orchestra, 1973; Grand Duo, 1988; Piano Concerto,
1985). The percussion ensemble also served as a backdrop to his work
with gamelan after 1975. By the time Harrison left
San Francisco in 1942 he had composed over 175 works (two of them
published in the New Music Quarterly),35
including several twelve-tone compositions and even some quarter-tone
pieces. He spent the year 1942–43 in Los Angeles, where he provided
piano accompaniments for the dance studio of Lester Horton (an
experimental West Coast choreographer who organized the first
multi-racial dance troupe in the nation and explored cross-cultural
themes in his works).36
Harrison also taught Labanotation, music history, and musical form to
UCLA dance students, and he studied composition with Arnold Schoenberg.
In contrast to Cage’s experience,37
Harrison found Schoenberg both supportive and helpful. Schoenberg
praised Harrison’s published piano works during weekly seminars,
helped him find his way through a compositional block, and cited him
in a list of promising young composers in a letter to Roy Harris in
1945.38
In the spring of 1943 Horton moved his dance company
to New York. Harrison followed some months later, initiating a
ten-year residence on the East Coast that rounded out his musical
education even as it proved to be the most difficult period of his
life. Though he was successful professionally, Harrison’s New York
years were for the most part troubled and unhappy, convincing him to
return to the West. He ultimately recognized that he was unsuited to
urban life on either coast and found a permanent residence in the
quiet California coastal town of Aptos, about eighty-five miles south
of San Francisco.
15
Harrison’s surviving public-school report cards come from Portland
(pre-1926), Woodland (1926–27), Stockton (1927–29), Berkeley
(1929–30), Redwood City (1931–33), and Burlingame (1934).
16
Harrison, interview, Nov. 21, 1995.
17
Harrison, personal communication, June 12, 1998.
18
Description, review, and photo in Miller and Lieberman, Lou
Harrison, 5 and fig. 3.
19
Harrison, lecture at the 56th American Humanist Association Conference
(Denver, Colorado), April 1997.
20
Among Harrison’s other works for early instruments are a series of
pieces for harpsichord, clavichord, or recorder (which he does not
currently authorize for performance); Binary Variations on ‘O
Sinner Man’ for Renaissance instruments; and a Serenade for
Three Recorders composed in New York in 1943 (see works catalog
listing in Miller and Lieberman, Lou Harrison). The only
complete recording of the harpsichord sonatas is by Linda Burman-Hall,
Musical Heritage Society 513988A.
21
Harrison, interview, March 8, 1994.
22
A postcard from Cowell to Harrison, dated September 11, 1935, seems to
refer to the first lesson. The original card is in Special Collections
in the University of California, Santa Cruz library and is reproduced
in Peter Garland, ed., A Lou Harrison Reader, 31.
23
These and other compositional processes are discussed in Harrison’s Music
Primer.
24
Despite some claims to the contrary, it appears that Harrison’s
employment at Mills began in the fall of 1937. For details of
conflicting information on this topic, see Miller and Lieberman, Lou
Harrison, chapter 1.
25
Harrison-Ives correspondence: originals in the Ives archive, Yale
University; copies in Harrison’s personal archive.
26
Cage/Harrison panel discussion at the Cornish School, Seattle,
Washington, January 1992. Videotape by Bob Campbell graciously made
available through the efforts of Jarrad Powell. Quotations from
unpublished John Cage material used with the permission of the John
Cage Trust.
27
Cage’s years in Seattle are discussed in my forthcoming article,
"Cultural Intersections: John Cage in Seattle (1938–40),"
which will appear in a collection of articles edited by David
Patterson and published by Garland Press.
28
Karen Bell-Kanner, Frontiers: The Life and Times of Bonnie Bird,
American Modern Dancer and Dance Educator (Amsterdam: Harwood
Academic Books, forthcoming). Harrison met Bird at the Mills College
1938 summer session, which ran from June 26 to August 6; Bird was
there for the first two weeks.
29
Published by C. F. Peters in 1961.
30
The development of the Cage/Harrison percussion ensemble is discussed
in Leta Miller, "The Art of Noise: John Cage, Lou Harrison, and
the West Coast Percussion Ensemble," Essays in American Music
3 (Garland, forthcoming).
31
For more on Harrison and dance, see Miller and Lieberman, Lou
Harrison, chapter 4, and Miller, "The Art of Noise."
32
Compact disc recordings of the flute concerto include: Musical
Heritage Society MHS 513616L; CRI CD-568; and Bis 272. The violin
concerto is available on Crystal CD853.
33
"Lou Harrison’s Mass to be Highlight of Festival," Santa
Cruz County Journal News, August 12, 1970.
34
Besides the flute and violin concerti cited above, he wrote Concerto
in Slendro for violin and percussion in 1961 and a Concerto for
Organ with Percussion in 1973.
35
Saraband and Prelude for Grandpiano (both composed in 1937): New
Music Quarterly XI/4, July 1938.
36
For more on Horton, see Larry Warren, Lester Horton: Modern Dance
Pioneer (New York and Basel: Marcel Dekker, 1977).
37
Cage commented that Schoenberg "never once led me to believe that
my work was distinguished in any way. He never praised my
compositions, and when I commented on other students’ work in class
he held my comments up to ridicule" (Calvin Tomkins, The Bride
and the Bachelors [New York and London: Penguin Books, 1962], 85).
38
Erwin Stein, ed. Arnold Schoenberg: Letters, trans. Eithne
Wilkins and Ernst Kaiser (N.Y.: St. Martin’s Press, 1964), 234.
|