Physics 125, Fall 1995 -- Lecture 16: Energy Conservation: Binding Energy, Energy Sources, Nuclear Energy

© Timothy E. Chupp, 1995

The Curve of Binding Energy

We now introduce the concept of binding energy (BE). In words, BE is the negative of the minimum work needed to separate a bound system into two pieces. Consider the ``bound system'' of the earth and a space ship at rest on its surface. The force which holds the two together, i.e. which binds the system, is of course gravity which has the magnitude

= G where .

Near the earth's surface (r = r) this is , but as r approaches infinity, the force becomes vanishingly small.

Now consider the space ship very far away, initially at rest. There will be a small force toward the earth and therefore it will accelerate, move closer to the earth where the force is stronger, accelerate more etc. At each point, its KE will be equal to the work done by gravity up to that point. Since the force is not constant, calculation of the work done requires the operation of summing the work for each short distance interval over which the force is approximately constant. This is called integrating the force:

The work need to remove the space ship from r to very far away is the negative of this, and thus the

The total energy of the system is = KE + BE. Therefore if it is initially very far away and at rest, = 0 + 0 which remains constant as the spaceship falls toward the earth.

4. If the spaceship starts at the earth's surface, what is the binding energy of the spaceship-earth system. Express your answer in terms of g and . If the total energy of the system is 0, that is at , KE=0 and BE=0, what is the KE of the spaceship as it leaves the earths surface. The corresponding velocity is called the escape velocity:

mv = mgr

5. Find the escape velocity for a He atom at the earth's surface and compare this to the rms velocity at 300 K.

We can draw a graph of BE as a function of separation and indicate the constant . The KE is given by KE = - BE as shown. Near the earth's surface, the change of binding energy over small distances is the well known BE = mgh. This can be derived with a few lines of calculus:

BE (BE) r

where (BE) = Gm = -mg

thus BE = mgr = mgh.

Now consider the BE of two protons. In this case, the force has magnitude given by

= k where and coul.

In contrast to the attractive, gravitational force, the electrical force is repulsive. Our definition of BE therefore gives

Two protons can come together only if the total energy is positive. Therefore consider two protons greatly separated with a large . As they move together, BE increases and KE decreases as shown.

BUT two protons can come together and form a bound system through the nuclear reaction

p + p d (pn) + e +

where d is the nucleus of deuterium (), the e is an electron and the is the new particle called the neutrino which was mentioned earlier and will soon be discussed in more detail. In any reaction, including a nuclear reaction, energy (including mc) and electric charge must be conserved. You can easily see that this is true for this reaction. Furthermore note that one proton has disappeared and a neutron has appeared. Whenever this happens or the reverse, i.e. a proton is transmuted into a neutron or vice versa, a neutrino must appear along with the electron or positron that insures conservation of electric charge.

The nuclear fusion reaction which is better written

.

can happen because protons within about m of each other exert nuclear forces. Nuclear forces are in fact stronger than the repulsive electric force, but cannot be expressed in the form used for gravitational and electric forces. In terms of BE, the nuclear binding can be shown by including a negative portion or well for m as shown above. In the case of deuterium, the well is 2.2 MeV deep. (1 MeV is a unit of energy based on the electron-volt or eV. 1 eV = Joule, a very small amount. 1 MeV = 1 Million or eV.

6. What is the velocity of a proton with KE=2.2 MeV?

The maximum positive BE is sometimes called the coulomb barrier which must be surmounted in order for the nuclear reaction to occur.

The curves of BE can be viewed as hills which the spaceships or protons roll up or down. That is, a space ship above the earth at rest will roll down the curve of BE toward the earth and a proton near another proton will roll away down the curve of BE. For the case of two protons, once they are within m of each other, they will fall into the well of binding energy releasing KE which is greater than that needed to surmount the coulomb barrier.

Sources of Useful Energy: Gravitational and Chemical

We now consider the sources of energy utilized by society. The major sources of energy now in use are gravitational energy (hydropower), chemical energy (fossil fuels), nuclear fission energy, nuclear radioactivity and solar power. Nuclear fusion energy the hypothetical source of the sun's heat, and matter-antimatter annihilation are sources which may become practical in the years to come.

In each case, we will use a figure of comparison, the useful energy avaliable per kg of ``fuel''. For example, hydropower is effected by building a dam of typically 100 m height which lets fall onto the turbines of a generator. For each kg of , mgh = 1000 J = 1 kJ. In this case of figure of comparison is 1 kJ/kg. We will soon provide a basis of comparison for the several sources of energy based on this figure of comparison and the nature of the waste products.

The used in hydropower had to be lifted to the 100m height in order to be useful. The agent responsible for this work is the sun which shines on each of the oceans with power of about 1 kW (1 kJ/s). For each kg of evaporated, 2,200 kJ of the sun's energy are needed. In order to lift each kg to a height of 10 km, typical of many clouds, only 100 kJ are needed for a total of 2,300 kJ/kg supplied by the sun for each 1 kJ/kg exploited by hydropower. This certainly does not seem to be an efficient use of the sun's power.

Chemical compounds are bound by electrical forces of varying strength. In breaking these bonds and forming new ones, KE is released. The burning of hydro-carbon compounds is most common. For example:

is methane abundantly produced by the metabolism of living things. Propane, is commonly used as cooking and lab gas. For each mole of C atoms burned, 250 kcal 1000 kJ is released. Thus chemical energy typically has 1000 kJ per 15 gm or 6x10 kJ/kg to offer as useful energy. For these simple hydro-carbons, only and are produced as waste products. Unfortunately, most fossil fuel is in the form of oil of varying grades of refinement and coal. In combustion of gasoline in automobiles for example, CO (carbon monoxide) and which is carcinogenic are produced due to incomplete burning and reaction of air and at high temperatures. Coal is mostly carbon and sulfur. The following reactions take place

and

and (sulfurous acid)

Sulfurous acid is the major component of Acid Rain. In addition, great amounts of carbon dust are produced and exhausted. Of course the emission of particulate and acid rain by products can be reduced but only at allegedly great expense to the industries which would be forced to retrofit their facilities. In the modern world, economy seems to be defined as the lowest possible cost of doing business and it seems very hard to establish the cost to the coal industry of polluting a lake in the Canadian wilderness.

Nuclear Energy

Nuclear energy resides in the bonds established by the nuclear forces. Since such forces are stronger than the electrostatic repulsion of the positively charged protons separated by less than m, we can expect at least /r = 1.44 MeV per nuclear bond. In fact nuclear bonds are as large as 8 MeV per nucleon (a nucleon is either a neutron or proton) for the most tightly bound nuclei like . The mass of a proton is kg and nuclear fuel can therefore provide about kJ/kg!

It is essential to bring a new kind of energy into the equation for nuclear energy: this is the equivalent energy of the mass: , the famous result of Einstein's special theory of relativity. Consider the set of nuclear reactions suggested by Hans Bethe as the sun's primary source of energy (hydrogen fusion):

the net result of this series of reactions can be written

The is the positively charged antiparticle of the electron called the positron. It has the same mass but opposite electric charge as the electron.

Even though the 4 protons must have sufficient KE to overcome the coulomb barrier, once they are close enough, the series of reactions will occur and provide more energy than was initially needed. This is because the sum of the masses of the 4 protons is greater than that of the , the positrons and neutrinos. The energy conservation principle applied to this reaction is

(note:

The masses of the and positron are given below where 1 A.M.U. is the atomic mass unit based on the scale for which the atom has mass 12 A.M.U. (1 A.M.U. = kg).

= 1.00782 A.M.U.

= 4.002596 A.M.U.

m(e) = 0.0005485

Applying this to the energy conservation equation, we find

MeV (0.0276 A.M.U.)

This set of fusion reactions is suggested as the sun's primary source of energy. This suggestion is a hard one to test, but physicists have been working for two decades to detect the neutrinos that are produced by the nuclear fusion reactions. These are the only particles that reach the earthbound observatory unaffected, i.e. they pass through the sun with very little probability of interacting. (This statement, believed valid in 1985, may reversed by 1987.) For the same reason, neutrinos are very hard to detect, in fact a volume of material several light years thick would be required to insure that an incident neutrino interacts. I have not written the complete set of nuclear fusion reactions which have the final result that four protons become one helium, positrons and neutrinos. It turns out that the currently detectable neutrinos do not come from the set of reactions written above but from a set of reactions that take place less than 1% of the time.

The 26.6 MeV avaliable for each atom formed is J. Therefore for each Joule of radiant energy (sunshine) atoms are formed. We can use this to predict two numbers: how long the sun can shine and how many neutrinos are currently incident on your head. For the first, you need to know the sun's mass, kg and that 75% of this mass is avaliable as H fuel. For the second, use the fact that on a sunny day, about 1 kW shines on each of the earth.

Hydrogen fusion may provide useful power for society. The challenge is to maintain a controlled fusion reaction, that is to contain a sufficient amount of the energy produced as heat, the KE of the protons which is necessary to surmount the coulomb barrier. This work is actively pursued especially at Princeton, MIT and the US National Laboratories at Livermore and Los Alamos. Though great progress has been made, the utilization of controlled hydrogen fusion is probably decades in the future.

Hydrogen fusion is exploited in a non-controllable way in the Teller-Ulam hydrogen bomb which has formed the centerpiece of US and Soviet nuclear arsenals since the mid 1950's.

The hydrogen bomb consists of a fission bomb (we will discuss the fission reactions soon), triggers, deuterium and hydrogen as fuels and a jacket of uranium which contains the energy of the fission bomb's explosion long enough to ignite the fusion fuel. It is a complex but compact device whose energy content is measured in kilotons or megatons of TNT, i.e. the energy avaliable from the equivalent chemical explosion:

1 ton = 1000 kg which provides kJ of chemical energy

Typical U.S. bombs are 100 kilotons and typical Soviet bombs are 1 Megaton. All together, the combined arsenals of the world contain at least 10,000 such devices.

Nuclear Fission and The History of its Discovery and Uses

Nuclear Fission

Nuclear fission is the process of a heavy nucleus (Z>90) breaking up into two roughly equal parts and possibly individual neutrons. In particular, the nuclei and (U is Uranium and Pu is Plutonium) break up as follows:

neutrons,

and similarly for . The products of fission for a single nucleus are not definitely predictable. N, the number of neutrons produced has an average value of 2.3. A and B are elements in the region of and = 45-56 i.e. Rh, Pd, Ag, Cd, In, Sn, Sb, Te, I, Xe, Cs and Ba with mass a and b between 80 and 160. Conservation of mass (energy) and charge (Z) require for that = 92 and a + b + N = 236.

The reason that these nuclei fission can be understood by considering the curve of binding energy which is shown for .

The nucleus in its bound state (the well to the right of the hump or barrier) is relatively stable, the half life is 24 million years. However if U is formed by the reaction

U + n (neutron) U

the product nucleus U will have sufficient excitation to surmount the barrier and break into the fission products. This excitation is due to the KE of the individual neutrons and protons in the nucleus and is analogous to the internal energy associated with the heat of a macroscopic object. When the nucleus fissions, the entire barrier energy, 210 MeV, becomes avaliable as the KE of the fission products. This is about 1 MeV per neutron or proton i.e. 10 kJ/kg!

The reaction written above is the basis for the uranium fission bomb. The U is found in nature today as 0.7% of the uranium, and the other 99.3% of natural uranium is U. Uranium was present when the earth was formed. U can also capture a neutron to form U which may fission, but this system is more tightly bound i.e. the well is deeper. Therefore higher energy neutrons are necessary (such as those produced in a thermonuclear bomb which cause fission of the U jacket shown on page 41). The probability that a neutron will be captured and therefore that the fission will occur is proportional to 1/v, the inverse of the neutron's velocity. U and Pu which can fission with lower energy or slow neutrons is much more effective for a fission bomb.

Pu does not occur naturally. It is formed in reactors which have some U through the series of reactions

U + n U (23.5 min)

U Np (2.35 day) + e +

Np Pu (24,000 yr) + e +

The times in parenthesis are the half-lives of each product. The half-life of U is 4.5 billion years, about the age of the earth. The half-life of U is 800 million years.

A Short History

Fission was discovered in the laboratory of Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann in Germany in 1938. This was followed by the explanation of Lise Meitner which served to clear up some of the mysteries surrounding results of bombarding heavy, radioactive materials such as radium and uranium with neutrons. The realization that much lighter elements were produced (Hahn and Strassmann identified Ba) along with more neutrons and energies typical of nuclear reactions was rapidly synthesized into the realization that a weapon of unprecedented explosive energy was possible. This explosion would be due to a chain reaction leading to exponential growth of the fission rate and the energy produced until the fuel is spent.

The discovery of fission may have been the final ``peace-time'' discovery of the young field of nuclear physics which was born in 1896 with the discovery by Bequerell that certain uranium salts caused a blackening of photographic film. The following list highlights some of the events before 1938:

1896 - Becquerel discovers radioactivity.

1897-99 - J.J. Thompson's investigations show the existence of the electron.

1898 - E. Rutherford discovers rays in Rn gas and deflects them magnetically to contrast with rays.

1900 - radiation was discovered by Villard - it is more difficult to shield than radiation.

1903 - and radiation are all shown to cause transmutation, that is changing the chemical form of an atom.

1903 - Rutherford shows rays are He nuclei.

1911 - E. Rutherford scatters particles from gold atoms (1904 - 1908) and discovers that some particles are scattered back toward the source as if a strongly repulsive object was a the center of the atom. This was of course the positively charged nucleus and gave way to Rutherford's model of the atom as a cloud of electrons surrounding a nucleus of positive charge.

1919 - Rutherford observes positively charged, longer ranged particles that s - protons. This was achieved by exposing nitrogen to particles from radium and was the first artificially induced radioactivity.

1932 - The neutron was discovered by Chadwick bombarding Be with alpha particles and observing C as the product. Charge conservation along with energy and momentum conservation require the existence of a neutral particle with a mass similar to the protons: the neutron.

1932 - Cockroft and Walton built the first high voltage accelerator which could give protons and other positive projectiles sufficient energy to surmount the coulomb barrier and undergo nuclear reactions. The observed reaction was H + Li 2He. Later that year Ernest Lawrence at Berkeley developed the cyclotron and observed the same reaction.

1932-38 Many elements were bombarded with particles and neutrons in the search for new elements. Those heavier than uranium were named transuranic elements. This new kind of alchemy produced new mysteries including that associated with bombarding U. Meitner's suggestion that fission occurred set into motion the development of nuclear weapons, the first chapter of which ended in the summer of 1945.

Developing Atomic Energy During the War

During the 1930's a great many European scientists, mostly Jewish, came to the U.S. fleeing from the political and social situations in their homelands. The list of names is long and well documented in the narrative by Laura Fermi Illustrious Immigrants published in 1968. Some key figures were H. Bethe, A. Einstein, E. Fermi, G. Gamow, G. Kistiakowsky, L.Szilard, E. Teller, S. Ulam, E. Wigner, V. Weisskopf and many others. The highlights of the birth of nuclear physics show that before 1940, physics research was concentrated in Europe. The birth and nurturing of Quantum Mechanics, the basis of modern physical thought, paralleled that of nuclear physics. The center of its development was the institute of Niels Bohr in Copenhagen.

With the scientists' emigration came the new ideas of physics as well as new channels of communication to European research. In particular, news of the suggestion of Meitner and its experimental confirmation quickly found its way to the recently landed Leo Szilard. Together with E. Wigner, Szilard mounted a campaign to bring the weapons potential of nuclear fission to the attention of F.D. Roosevelt, the U.S. president. They enlisted Einstein as a co-signer of a letter to Roosevelt in the hope that the name of the famous physicist would bring more rapid attention. This was in the summer of 1939, fully 18 months before the US declared war on Germany and Japan. A great deal of research took place during those 18 months but the US decision to make an all out effort to exploit nuclear fusion came in early December, 1941, just before the bombing of Pearl Harbor on December 7.

The work of the Manhattan Project took place on many fronts for there were many problems to solve. First came the question of how much material was needed for a bomb: the fission chain reaction would take place only if the neutrons produced in a single fission reaction had sufficient probability to be absorbed and beget another fission reaction. In fact, on the average, each neutron absorbed must lead to the fission of more than one more atom in order for the chain reaction to grow. The probability of neutron absorption depends on the density of the absorbers, the U or Pu. A sufficiently high density for an explosion is called the critical density which is often misnamed the critical mass. Only a few kg of fissionable material is needed for a weapon. The study of neutron absorption probability on U and Pu took place at laboratories in Chicago and Berkeley among others. Another problem was producing the fuel, i.e. extracting the 0.7% U in natural uranium and producing Pu. Oak Ridge Laboratory in Tennessee and Hanford in Washington State became central in this effort. The critical density would be achieved by a compressive explosion which was developed in part at Los Alamos, New Mexico which, under the direction of J.R. Oppenheimer, became the center of the wartime research and the site of the bombs' construction. These efforts all came together by the summer of 1945, after the surrender of the Axis in Europe, but while the war with Japan in the Pacific was still raging. By mid July, three bombs had been constructed, two with Pu and one with U. On July 16, 1945 at 5:30 A.M. at Alamogordo, N.M., the first atomic bomb built by man was exploded. The intensity of the blast took by surprise even those who had calculated its potential, for such a physical experience cannot be equated with a number on a piece of paper. (If I were to show you a spark 200 times larger than one you had seen previously, you would not really know what to expect. The Alamogordo Test was equivalent to simultaneously exploding about 20,000 tons of TNT. In a previous test, 100 tons of TNT were exploded.) But the carnage at Hiroshima and its after effects were a sort of destruction that even the experience of the Alamogordo test could not foretell.

The decision of how to use the two remaining bombs lay with the military and ultimately with President Truman. However four of the physicists who led the efforts to produce the weapons were honored with the opportunity to advise the President. They were Arthur Compton, Oppenheimer, E.O. Lawrence and Enrico Fermi. A seriously debated option was to stage a demonstration of the weapon's destructive power for the Japanese Emperor and military leaders. This was probably the last time scientists have been involved in the formation of nuclear weapon policy, though Szilard in particular, foreseeing the proliferation of nuclear weapons campaigned strongly to prevent the consolidation to the military of atomic energy development.

On August 6, 1945, a bomb of U was exploded over Hiroshima and on August 9, 1945, one of Pu was exploded over Nagasaki. All three of the first atomic bombs built worked. There were no duds. Nor were there any nuclear weapons in the world on August 10. Today there are more than 10,000 most of which are controlled by the US and USSR. Britain, France, India, China and probably Israel are also members of this Nuclear Club, and other, developing nations are aspiring to become members. It is interesting to note that Japan, certainly technologically capable of producing nuclear weapons will not do so.

The Aftermath

The events since 1945 can be quickly summarized. The highlights are the development of the thermonuclear or hydrogen bomb in the US in 1952 and shortly thereafter in the USSR, the deployment of nuclear weapons on long-range bombers (B-52's), intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM's), submarines (SLBM's), cruise missiles (ALCM's etc.) and of course the development of commercial nuclear power in the US and other countries since the 1960's. One final note which relates the peaceful application of atomic energy in power production and weapons: Pu is most abundantly produced in reactors as a waste product. It is both poisonous and of course a weapons fuel.

A Comparison of Energy Sources

We have come sufficiently far in our discussion to produce the table which compares the different sources of energy. We use two bases of comparison: the energy avaliable per kg and the waste products. The two entries at the end of the table: nuclear fusion and matter-antimatter conversion are not practical though research is in progress on both fronts (the matter-antimatter work is pursued by, among others, the US Air Force).

Table: A Comparison of Energy Sources

The -?- are entered because the anticipated waste products are negligible compared to those for chemical and nuclear fission power. Radioactive waste will be discussed in the next section.

Conspicuously missing from this table is direct solar power. (Of course all of these sources of energy indirectly rely on solar or stellar energy.) Solar power has found practical use for home heating in some climates and certainly reduces the dependence on the other commercial power sources in any climate. For electrical power generation, solar energy is not yet competitive because the energy required to construct a device that harnesses this energy is greater than the energy the device can produce during its practical life. Research continues on this front with the most promise being the efficient conversion of solar to chemical energy, e.g. the separation by electrolysis of HO into H and O.

Nuclear Radioactivity

There are three types of nuclear radioactivity: , and . These are due to different kinds of nuclear decay and the rays etc. are particles emitted when a nucleus decays. Each of these types of radiation has unique characteristics, but one thing all have in common is the result of passing through matter: they ionize the atoms in the material through which they pass, losing kinetic energy. Ionization is the process of tearing electrons away from the material's atoms and occurs due to the strong electrical forces. It is ionization that leads to the harmful effects of radiation to be discussed soon.

decay

Alpha decay is the emission of a He nucleus:

Po Pb + He

Note that this reaction conserves both Z and A, respectively the subscript and superscript on the elemental symbol. decay takes place primarily with heavy elements in the uranium, thorium and actinium series.

The range of particles in matter is very short, a fraction of a millimeter. This is the reason that a single playing card or piece of paper is effective shielding of s. This is also the reason that radiation is particularly biologically harmful: the entire KE is deposited in a small volume.

decay

Beta decay occurs when a neutron within the nucleus transforms into a proton:

n p + e +

The neutrino () always accompanies such a process. Note that charge is conserved as expected. The decay of the free neutron is a process that occurs in nature with a half-life of about 900 s (15 min). Free protons cannot decay due to energy conservation since mc for the proton is less than that for the neutron. However their are nuclei which are neutron deficient ( i.e. they would prefer more neutrons) for which positron decay or the process of capturing atomic electrons can occur:

O N + e + (positron decay)

Bi + e Pb + (electron capture)

The electrons have much longer range than particles and are often called minimum ionizing particles. However when they do slow down in matter, they abundantly produce X-rays called brehmsstrahlung. This is the principle of the X-ray machines used so commonly in dental and medical work.

radiation

Gamma radiation arises when a nucleus is left in an excited state, usually following decay. The nucleus is a bound system, and like an atom it has energy levels. Transitions among the energy levels require that energy be removed or added to the nucleus. When an excited state decays to the ground state or a lower energy excited state, a specific amount of energy is released in the form of a -ray. The -ray has particle-like properties, in particular it carries momentum as well as energy, but it is a form of electromagnetic energy just as radio waves, light and X-rays are. The -ray carries the signature of the nucleus from which it was emitted. The sodium-iodide detector and pulse-height analyzer shown in lecture can be used to identify the source of -rays and identify the material in a substance.

Gamma-rays are minimum ionizing particles. Their major interaction with matter is that of knocking electrons out of the atoms. These electrons can leave the material, ionize atoms in the material and produce brehmsstrahlung.

The Harmful Effects of Radiation

Nuclear radiation can be harmful to life. Of course there is a natural background to which we are all exposed. The major components of this background are the radioactive isotopes present in the material around us ( e.g. K and uranium) and cosmic-rays, particles that bombard the earth's atmosphere from space. The atmosphere at sea level is much more effective as shielding than that at the altitude of Denver or at 10 km, the altitude of commercial airline traffic.

A system of units has emerged from the understanding of the harmful effects. These units became news with the recent accident in the USSR.

Curie - This is a unit of activity: 1 Cu = 3.7x10 disintegrations per second.

rad (radiation absorbed dose) - This is a measure of the amount of energy deposited in a given mass of e.g. tissue or HO: 1 rad = 0.01 J/kg.

rem (equivalent dose) - This takes into account the different effective harmfulness of different kinds of radiation through a factor Q once called RBE for relative biological effectiveness.

RBE's for Different Radiations

For 1 rad of electrons, you have 1 rem. For 1 rad of s you have 20 rem. The much greater RBE for s etc. is due to the fact the energy is deposited in a much smaller volume.

Exposure to radiation depends on the rate at which the ionization is produced. Federal and state regulations set limits on both the rate and integrated dose. For Massachusetts, the limits are

NRC Regulations for Radiation Workers

1250 millirem per 3 months or up to 3 rem per Quarter but less than 5 rem per year

Regulations for Minors and The General Public

10% of this

The harmful result of radiation exposure follows from the ionization of biological material, mostly water.

HO + radiation HO + e

These ions quickly interact forming the radicals OH, H, H and OH, HO (hydrogen peroxide). These newly formed radicals interact with the atoms of the cell and chromosomes, breaking long chains etc. The result of all of this may be:

- early death for the cell

- prevention or delay of cell division

- genetic modification which is passed on to subsequent cell generations

The results may be rapid onset of radiation sickness as the cells are poisoned, mutant, cancer causing cell genesis and genetic damage that is passed on to future generations. The most frequent cancers appear to be leukemia, cancer of the red bone marrow and lung cancer and breast cancer among women. Thyroid cancer and bone sarcoma occur at a lower rate per dose. Data show that for exposure of 1 million people to 100 millirem (10 man-rem), 10 men and 15 women will contract cancers.

In fact knowledge of the relationship of exposure and its harmful effects rests on sparse data collected mostly in the aftermath of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and accidental exposures. It is on these data, however, that regulations are set.

Figure 1: Two dimensional elastic collisions of two equal mass objects.

About this document ...

Physics 125

This document was generated using the LaTeX2HTML translator Version 95.1 (Fri Jan 20 1995) Copyright © 1993, 1994, Nikos Drakos, Computer Based Learning Unit, University of Leeds.

The command line arguments were:
latex2html -split 0 -link 0 -no_navigation sixt.tex.

The translation was initiated by Jill Boltman on Fri Oct 27 15:41:11 EDT 1995


Jill Boltman
Fri Oct 27 15:41:11 EDT 1995