PEER REVIEW ASSESSMENT SHEET FOR ASSIGNMENT No.
4
Words from JKP:
In the interest in time, and because several of the students did not have the assignment done, I did not do this peer review. This was one of the more important ones as I soon realized that students really did not understand the concept of resonance. However, I believe more classroom instruction was needed before asking them to draw resonance structures of their complicated molecules.
Evaluation Sheet: Assignment 4
Whose paper are you reviewing?______________________
Reviewer’s name?______________________
Answer the following yes/no questions. If the answer is no, make the necessary corrections
in the space provided.
Circle the answer
I. Resonance Structures
1. Resonance form 1
A. Is the connectivity maintained? Yes No
B. Are all electrons and charges
accounted for? Yes No
2. Resonance form 2
A. Is the connectivity maintained? Yes No
B. Are all electrons and charges
accounted for? Yes No
3. Resonance form 3
A. Is the connectivity maintained? Yes No
B. Are all electrons and charges Yes No
accounted for?
II. Contributions
A. Are the relative contributions rational? Yes No