Plot Summary:
The Caves of Steel (1954) is set three thousand
years into the future. Humans live on Earth in completely enclosed
underground cities (caves of steel) while their robot servants work
in mines and farms in the open country. Another type of human, the
Spacers, live in outer space and on many other planets outside the
Solar System. They have 350 year lifespans and are free from disease.
One of these spacers, Roj Sarton, is killed in a Spacer colony just
outside New York City. Elijah Baley, a human detective from New York,
is assigned to investigate this murder case. Much to Baley's dislike,
the Spacers insist that he have a android partner, R. Daneel Olivaw,
to assist him with the case. Baley and Olivaw eventually discover the
murderer and become friends in the process.
1. What is the robot's role/function? Why was it
created?
There are two types of robots in this novel: the laborers
and human assistants. Daneel Olivaw, the robot detective and Elijah
Baley's partner, is programmed with a strong sense of justice and is
perfect for his role as investigator. The robots in this story, while
seemingly happy and well-behaved, are really just the servants of
humanity. Humans are protected from harm incurred by robots becase
they are programmed with the Three Laws of
Robotics.
2. How human is it? How human is it meant to
be?
Daneel Olivaw is designed to look indentical to a human
being, specifically, he looks exactly like the Spacer who was
murdered. Daneel even has the ability to eat, presumably to make
humans more comfortable with his presence: the useless food is later
removed from a "food sac." After Baley's accusations that Olivaw is
actually human, the android peels the skin from his arm and shows his
circuitry. At one point in the novel the humanoid shape of robots is
justified by the argument that the humanoid form is the best
generalized ans useful form.
3. How do humans react to it?
There are two basic attitudes towards robots in this
novel: the Earthmen who distrust robots and fear that they will take
their jobs, and the Spacers who advocate human/robot cooperation. The
Medievalists, a radical "Luddite" group that calls for a return to
primitive life, are extremely ani-robot. Baley is extremely
distrustful of Daneel at first, fearing that if the robot solves the
case first he will lose his job. Baley's reaction to Daneel is
typical of most Earthmen.
4. What are the consequences of the robot in
the work?
Daneel, while helping Baley solve the murder case, also
has a more important role: he changes Baley's attitude towards
robots. Near the end of the novel, the once anti-robot Baley trusts
Daneel more than anybody else. Baley even starts to agree with the
Spacers that humans and robots should work together to colonize the
Galaxy. One of the final scenes of the novel is Baley and Daneel
walking arm-in-arm; Daneel helped Baley see that robots and humans
can live together. A robot also unwittingly become an accomplice in
murder. Sammy, a robot office worker, is ordered to carry a weapon
over the open land (which humans cannot tolerate) and bring it
undetected into the Spacer colony. The murderer, who entered the
colony normally, takes the weapon from the robot and completes the
crime. Since the robot did not know the motives for its actions and
did not actually kill the victim, it did not violate the
Three Laws of Robotics.
5. What ideas did it introduce to the theme of
robot? / Conclusion:
Like many of Asimov's other robot stories, Caves of
Steel tries to banish the stereotype of the "evil robot."
Asimov's robots are not something to be feared, and are not
abominations of nature created by humans. They are fundamentally good
creations, governed by the Three Laws of
Robotics, and will not turn on their masters. Daneel and the
other robots are not threats to human jobs, or beings that will
eventually replace humans, but they are creations that will help
humans and lead to a better way of life for all.