MATURE STYLE
(1961–1998)
Harrison’s return to California after his East Coast odyssey also
marked a reopening of his ties to Asia. Though he had been fascinated
by Chinese music and Indonesian gamelan since the 1930s, he did not
visit Asia until 1961 when he was invited to the East-West Music
Encounter in Tokyo. Funded by a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation,
Harrison boarded a freighter on March 25 for the journey across the
Pacific. Along the way, he made a study of pentatonic modes with pure
intervals and, using two of these modes, wrote a new work: a concerto
for solo violin accompanied by an orchestra of percussion and keyboard
instruments—six triangles, six gongs, four suspended galvanized
garbage cans, two tack pianos, and celesta—which he titled Concerto
in Slendro. (Slendro is an Indonesian pentatonic mode with
no half steps, or, as Harrison describes it, one with "wide
seconds and narrow thirds." There are many varieties of slendro,
but they all lack semitones, in contrast to pelog, a hemitonic
mode having "narrow seconds and wide thirds.")
Following the Tokyo conference, the Rockefeller
Foundation funded a trip to a second Asian country of Harrison’s
choice. He had arranged to visit Thailand, but was seduced by the
beauties of Korean music from recordings brought to Tokyo by one of
the most influential scholars of Korean traditional music, Dr. Lee Hye-Ku.
Harrison abruptly changed his plans and went to Korea instead. With
additional help from the Rockefeller Foundation, he brought Lee to
California later that year, and returned to Korea himself for three
and a half months the following summer. Harrison studied Korean
instruments, including the double-reed p’iri, and worked with
Lee on a history of Korean music (only partially completed). He
coupled his second trip with a visit to Taiwan as well, where he
studied cheng (psaltery) with the renowned master Liang
Tsai-Ping.
The decade following Harrison’s trips to Asia was
marked by a devotion to, and exploration of, Korean and Chinese music.
He composed for the instruments he had studied, built replicas of
them, and taught his students to play them; he wrote works for
ensembles of mixed Asian and Western instruments (Pacifika Rondo,
Music for Violin with Various Instruments, and others); and he
lectured widely on various traditional Asian musics. He even founded a
Chinese music ensemble with his student Richard Dee and his partner
William Colvig, whom he met in San Francisco in 1967. Together the
trio presented hundreds of concerts of classical Chinese music
throughout California, often joined by the singer and cheng
player Lily Chin and the poet Kenneth Rexroth, who would narrate and
read his own translations of Chinese poems.
Harrison earned a living during his early Aptos
years primarily through non-musical jobs (such as that at the animal
hospital), supplemented by working as an accompanist for several dance
studios in the San Francisco area. His love of teaching led him to
take a part-time position at San Jose State University in 1967, where
he offered courses in orchestration, composition, and world music
until 1983. (He also taught for short periods at Stanford, the
University of Southern California, and Mills College, and, for many
years, offered a popular world music course and ran the gamelan at
nearby Cabrillo College.)
The period was also one of intense political
activism, prompted both by the atomic bomb attacks on Japan and by the
arms race and nuclear testing of the following decades. Harrison
bought his own Geiger counter, which he set up in front of his cottage
and read daily, and wrote a short Political Primer, part of
which he set to music using the Geiger counter as background
commentary.145
Equal temperament came to represent for him an undifferentiated
grayness, symbolizing the leveling tendencies of modern industrial
society. Coupled with serialism—which by now he had largely
abandoned as a primary compositional tool—he called for this
"mechanized post-industrial tuning" in several political
works of the time, including anti-bomb movements in Pacifika Rondo
(1963) and Nova Odo (1961–68). The latter includes a Morse
code message in the woodwinds ("Class struggle between church and
state was won; will layman win struggle against military?"), as
well as the voices of children who appeal for sanity in the face of an
escalating Cold War.
The Vietnam War (particularly with its persistent
media images of Americans killing Asians) only exacerbated
Harrison’s outrage and inspired the Cabrillo Music Festival’s 1968
concert of "Peace Pieces"—a protest in sympathy with the
increasingly virulent anti-war demonstrations on college campuses
throughout the country. Harrison actively supported the pacifist
non-commercial radio KPFA in Berkeley and became increasingly
outspoken in support of humanitarian and ecological causes. He has
continued his political activism to the present day, waging personal
battles against noise pollution, economic waste, and the despoiling of
nature (he uses exclusively paper made from kenaf, a member of the
hibiscus family, and in 1997 began building a straw-bale house in the
Mojave desert as a getaway). He has continued to compose political
works, the most dramatic example from his mature style period being Homage
to Pacifica (1991), which blends sardonic commentaries on American
imperialism with a celebration of Native American culture and a vision
of a united world.
Meeting Colvig in 1967 (see plate 6) spurred the
instrument-building side of Harrison’s life as well. An electrician
and amateur musician, Colvig helped Harrison explore a variety of
tuning systems by constructing metallophones and measuring their
frequency ratios with an oscilloscope. The two men also built an
accurate and versatile monochord, on which they could easily set up
and compare different modes, both those of ancient or non-Western
musics and those of their own invention. They then transferred these
modes to other instruments via a specially constructed harp,
appropriately dubbed a "transfer harp."
The pair’s first gamelan, built in 1971 for
Harrison’s opera Young Caesar, was not intended as a replica
of an Indonesian original but as a percussion ensemble in just
intonation, with metallophones tuned in pure non-beating intervals in
D major. Harrison and Colvig used readily available materials:
aluminum slabs and conduit tubing for keys and stacked #10 tin cans
for resonators. Discarded oxygen tanks cut to random lengths and
struck with flattened baseball bats added a bell-like timbre to the
ensemble, which was rounded out with suspended garbage cans and a
small organ (see plate 5). Noting the similarities of this home-made
orchestra to an Indonesian ensemble, Harrison and Colvig dubbed it
"An American Gamelan" and now refer to it fondly as
"Old Granddad." Harrison composed three works for this
unique orchestra: Young Caesar (since rescored for Western
instruments), La Koro Sutro (1972, with chorus), and the Suite
for Violin with American Gamelan (composed jointly with Richard
Dee in 1974 and now available in two alternative versions for Western
instruments).
Unlike Old Granddad, two later gamelan built by
Harrison and Colvig (one for San Jose State University in the late
1970s and the other for Mills College in the early 1980s) were modeled
directly on traditional Indonesian percussion ensembles. The two men
have constructed numerous other instruments as well: harps, bell
trees, plucked and bowed psalteries, and drums built from suspended
wooden crates, to name a few.
Harrison engaged with the last major influence on
his mature style beginning in 1975 when he met the renowned Indonesian
gamelan master and teacher K.R.T. Wasitodiningrat (Pak Cokro) at the
Center for World Music in Berkeley. Under Pak Cokro, Harrison began a
disciplined study of traditional gamelan instruments, musical styles,
and performance practices, a project he undertook with the same fervor
he had brought to previous endeavors. He learned to play most of the
instruments of the ensemble, mastered works from the classical
literature, and gained an in-depth understanding of the structure of
gamelan music from various regions within Indonesia.
Soon Harrison began composing for traditional
gamelan; his first works for the ensemble appeared in 1976. Within two
years, however, he was combining the Indonesian orchestra with Western
solo instruments (Main Bersama-sama for french horn and gamelan
and Threnody for Carlos Chávez for viola and gamelan).
Harrison’s more than fifty gamelan works include pieces for gamelan
alone, gamelan with voices, or gamelan with solo instruments (among
them a Concerto for Piano with Javanese Gamelan [1987] in which
the piano must be tuned to the Indonesian instruments). Rather than
exploring the extended instrumental techniques used by some of his
contemporaries (such as bowing, rather than striking, the bonang—knobbed
gongs laid horizontally on rope supports), Harrison uses the
instruments of the ensemble in a traditional manner, adapts standard
organizational structures, and welcomes idiomatic elaboration by
performers. His personal voice is heard in the novel instrumental
combinations, in the just intonation tuning systems he has used for
his three sets of instruments, and in the mixing of compositional
processes. Although Harrison had become adept at simulating gamelan
sounds on Western instruments long before his studies with Pak Cokro,
his new knowledge of traditional practices enabled him to do more than
just mimic its timbres: he was now equipped to utilize Indonesian
compositional processes as well. Such cultural transference is
apparent in works like the Fourth Symphony, one movement of
which calls for a baritone chanting California Indian "Coyote
Tales"146
over a murmuring percussion accompaniment evoking Javanese sounds. In
the second movement of his Piano Trio, he introduced typical
gamelan elaboration patterns such as mipil (a oscillation
between two pitches) or cèngkok (longer embellishment patterns
arriving periodically at unisons with the main melody).
The 1980s and 1990s have witnessed a revival of
Harrison’s interest in standard Western ensembles. To date, he has
composed two operas, four symphonies, and a series of chamber works
for various instrumental combinations (string quartet, piano trio,
etc.). Despite repeated vows to retire, he has not stopped, or even
reduced his compositional activity. Between 1994 and 1997 alone he
completed five major commissions: incidental music for a radio
broadcast of Eugene O’Neill’s Lazarus Laughed; a fanfare
for the San Francisco Symphony entitled Parade for M.T.T.
(honoring musical director Michael Tilson Thomas’s first year with
the orchestra); Rhymes with Silver for the dancer and
choreographer Mark Morris and the cellist Yo-Yo Ma; a solo work for
Japanese shamisen (Suite for Sangen); and a Concerto for
P’i-P’a (a pear-shaped Chinese lute) with String Orchestra
commissioned by New York City’s Lincoln Center.
145Harrison’s
Political Primer is published in Frog Peak Anthology
(Hanover, N.H.: Frog Peak Music, 1992), 77–83.
146Two
of the tales are taken (by permission) from Bruce Walter Barton’s The
Tree at the Center of the World: A Story of the California Missions
(Santa Barbara: Ross-Erikson Publishers, 1980). The third was written
by the Wintu, Daniel-Harry Steward.
|